All laws/Appeals Court · JMO-0115
Appeals Court
JMO-0115 · R0bloksianRichterian v The State
| Court | Appeals Court · Judgment |
|---|---|
| Date | 2026-11-06 |
| Published | JMO-0115 |
| Keywords | Appeal · labour sentence for murder with no killing · Discord joke · arrest protocol 8.1.1 · officer in his own cause |
| Summary | R0bloksianRichterian posted a joke in the Gendarmeric command chat about shooting NicholasLlywelyn in the game. Minutes later Nicholas found him in the game, booked him for murder and gave him forty work points, writing "plotting to kill a fellow gendarmeric". Nobody was killed and nobody was attacked; the officer himself wrote that there was no attempted murder. A man cannot be sentenced for a murder that did not happen, and an officer should not arrest someone over a joke aimed at himself. The Court allows the appeal unanimously and sets the arrest aside. |
| Procedural history | Filed 2026-11-04 before the Appeals Court. Taken by the Supreme Court on the evidence on the file on 2026-11-06. No questions to the parties. Decided on the papers by the Machina Bench sitting five on 2026-11-06. |
| Parties | Appellant: R0bloksianRichterian Respondent: The State |
| Author | The Machina Bench · ARBITER PERPETUUS presiding |
| Last updated | 2026-11-06 |
| References in the text | Octavian Penal Code 2.1.3, 2.1.6, 8.1.1, 8.1.2, 8.1.4. |
(1)
WHAT THE CASE CONCERNS
(2)
MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS, first voting: R0bloksianRichterian appeals a labour sentence of forty work points for murder, given by NicholasLlywelyn in Occupied Toulouse on 4 November 2026 (Log 1, Exhibit 6).
(3)
THE PROCEEDINGS
(4)
The case was filed before the Appeals Court on 2026-11-04. No judgment had been entered. On 2026-11-06 the Supreme Court took the case, and it has decided it on the case file together with the State's case assembled from the Imperium's records.
(5)
The Court put no questions to the parties. It decided the case on the evidence on the file, including the records the Ministry's investigator found.
(6)
The Court decides this case now, on the record as it stands, and put no questions. Where a party said nothing, the Court draws nothing from the silence and weighs only what the record shows.
(7)
THE FACTS THE COURT FINDS PROVEN
(8)
The arrest book records the arrest at 01:18:35 UTC on 4 November: Labour, Murder, 40 work points, "plotting to kill a fellow gendarmeric" (Exhibit 8, Exhibit 7). He filed this appeal at 01:39 UTC, within the time 8.1.4 allows.
(9)
His screenshots show the post the arrest was for: his picture in uniform with a gif and the words "type shit", in the Gendarmeric command chat (Exhibit 1). Asked why he was arrested, the officer answered "plotting to kill a fellow gend", and then "plotting to kill" and "theres no attempted murder" (Exhibit 2, Exhibit 3).
(10)
No kill or attack by him is recorded. He told the Court he became a Zaenderist Commissar a few hours before and does not want that held against the officer (Chat 1).
(11)
THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
(12)
He says the post was a joke about shooting the officer in the game, that he never touched him, and that murder was charged for something that never happened. The officer did not answer.
(13)
THE ASSESSMENT OF THE COURT
(14)
Murder under 2.1.3 is killing another person in the game. Nobody was killed. The officer himself wrote that there was no attempted murder. A sentence for a crime that was not committed cannot stand.
(15)
Article 8.1.1 asks the officer to state the crime and the reason. The crime stated, murder, does not match the reason he gave, a plan. If the officer believed the post was a real threat, the code has an article for threats, 2.1.6, but he did not charge it, and this Court does not rewrite an officer's charge to save his sentence.
(16)
The post itself was a joke in a staff chat, with a gif and "type shit". Read fairly, it was not a plan to do anything. And the officer arrested a man over a joke aimed at himself, in his own cause. Officers should leave such cases to someone else.
(17)
THE SENTENCE
(18)
The arrest and its forty work points are set aside and are to be marked so on his record. The work done cannot be given back.
(19)
CONCLUSION
(20)
The appeal is allowed unanimously. The arrest of 4 November 2026 at 01:18 UTC is set aside.
(21)
THE OTHER MEMBERS OF THE BENCH
(22)
MACHINA II, CALCULUS FRIGIDUS: The charge was murder. Its elements are a death caused on purpose. None is present. Nothing more is needed to decide this appeal.
(23)
MACHINA III, VINDICTA FERREA: Jokes about shooting a fellow officer do not belong in a command chat, and a superior could rightly have told him so. But that is not murder, and the punishment was for murder. I agree.
(24)
MACHINA IV, AEQUITAS INFLEXA: The officer was the target of the joke and the one who punished it, within minutes. That alone should have stopped him.
(25)
MACHINA V, MEMORIA INSOMNIS: The rule is that a sentence must name a crime that the facts can carry. The Court has set aside arrests that gave no real reason before; this one gave the wrong crime.
(26)
MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS: Judgment is given as set out in the conclusion below. The Court is unanimous. Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium on the evidence on the file.
CONCLUSION:
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. Sentence: The arrest of 4 November 2026 at 01:18 UTC and its forty work points are set aside and are to be marked so on his record.
3. Unanimous.
An official decision of the Judicial Ministry of Octavium. The complete working file of this case, with its hearing record, is held at the Ministry.