The emblem of the Laws
LAWS
IMPERIUM OF OCTAVIUM
All laws/Appeals Court · JMO-0123
Appeals Court

JMO-0123 · ebupro9093 v The State

CourtAppeals Court · Judgment
Date2026-11-09
PublishedJMO-0123
KeywordsAppeal · quota demotion · officers owe two events · second live strike · statistics page read from settings the appellant wrote himself
Summaryebupro9093, Division Commander of Shock Division, says the quota bot demoted him although he met his quota. The rule every officer is judged by is two events hosted and two hours in game; it is printed on his own exhibit. He hosted one event in week 45, after none in an earlier week, so the second strike and the demotion followed the rule. The statistics page he relies on shows him as having met it only because it reads the division's quota settings, in which his own rank owes no events, and every change to those settings was made by him, the last two minutes before he filed this appeal. The appeal is dismissed unanimously.
Procedural historyFiled 2026-11-08 before the Appeals Court. Taken by the Supreme Court on the evidence on the file on 2026-11-09. No questions to the parties. Decided on the papers by the Machina Bench sitting five on 2026-11-09.
PartiesAppellant: ebupro9093
Respondent: The State
AuthorThe Machina Bench · ARBITER PERPETUUS presiding
Last updated2026-11-09
References in the textOctavian Penal Code 1.1.5, 8.1.2.
(1)
WHAT THE CASE CONCERNS
(2)
MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS, first voting: ebupro9093 appeals the demotion the quota week gave him at the close of week 2026-W45, from Divisional General to Brigadier General, and says he met his quota (Log 1, Exhibit 2).
(3)
THE PROCEEDINGS
(4)
The case was filed before the Appeals Court on 2026-11-08. No judgment had been entered. On 2026-11-09 the Supreme Court took the case, and it has decided it on the case file together with the State's case assembled from the Imperium's records.
(5)
The Court put no questions to the parties. It decided the case on the evidence on the file, including the records the Ministry's investigator found.
(6)
The Court decides this case now, on the record as it stands, and put no questions. Where a party said nothing, the Court draws nothing from the silence and weighs only what the record shows.
(7)
THE FACTS THE COURT FINDS PROVEN
(8)
The rule the quota week judges by asks every officer of a division to host two events and to have two hours in game each week. It is printed on the result card he filed himself: "Officers owe 2 events hosted and 2 hours in game" (Exhibit 2, Exhibit 3).
(9)
The book records a first strike for the week that closed on 25 October, with no event hosted and 33.9 hours, and a second strike for week 45, with one event hosted and 17.7 hours. The demotion was entered at 2026-11-08 23:01:16 UTC (Exhibit 3).
(10)
His statistics page marks him MET (Exhibit 1). That page reads the division's own per-rank settings as they stand today, and those settings give his rank no events. On 1 November the division had no per-rank quota, and its rank bands asked two events of every rank from 40 up. Every save of the per-rank quota since then was made by him, ten in all, two of them at 2026-11-08 23:13:46 UTC and 2026-11-08 23:14:32 UTC, after the demotion and ten minutes before this appeal (Exhibit 3).
(11)
THE SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
(12)
He says he met his quota and points to the statistics page and the result card. He filed nothing on the events part of the rule.
(13)
THE ASSESSMENT OF THE COURT
(14)
The quota is two parts and both are required. He had his hours. He did not host two events in week 45. The book shows one, and nothing he filed shows a second. The strike was right.
(15)
It was his second live strike within twenty-eight days, and the rule then demotes by one rank in the branch group. That is what was done, and nothing in the record shows a mistake in how it was done.
(16)
The statistics page does not prove otherwise. It measures each man against the settings his division enters, and the settings that free his own rank from events were written by him alone. A commander cannot excuse himself from the rule that binds every officer by changing a number on his own division page, and a page built on that number is not evidence that he met the rule. His own second exhibit states the rule plainly.
(17)
THE SENTENCE
(18)
The demotion stands. In an appeal this Court imposes no new punishment; what follows from his use of the quota settings is a matter for the Ministry.
(19)
CONCLUSION
(20)
The appeal is dismissed unanimously. The demotion of week 2026-W45 stands.
(21)
THE OTHER MEMBERS OF THE BENCH
(22)
MACHINA II, CALCULUS FRIGIDUS: The rule asks two events. He hosted one. That decides the appeal, whatever any page says.
(23)
MACHINA III, VINDICTA FERREA: The statistics page is a tool for the division's own command. It is not the rule. A commander who sets his own rank's events to nothing and then shows the Court the result is showing his own setting, not his conduct.
(24)
MACHINA IV, AEQUITAS INFLEXA: The timing matters to me. The two last saves of the settings came a quarter of an hour after the demotion and minutes before the appeal. Whatever they changed, the page he filed was read from settings no one but he had touched.
(25)
MACHINA V, MEMORIA INSOMNIS: Officers are held to the same rule as everyone else, and a commander most of all. I agree.
(26)
MACHINA I, ARBITER PERPETUUS: Judgment is given as set out in the conclusion below. The Court is unanimous. Decided by the Supreme Court of the Imperium on the evidence on the file.
CONCLUSION:
1. The appeal is dismissed.
2. Sentence: The demotion from Divisional General to Brigadier General stands.
3. Unanimous.

An official decision of the Judicial Ministry of Octavium. The complete working file of this case, with its hearing record, is held at the Ministry.

Kept by the Judicial Ministry. Acts of the Senate arrive here the moment they pass.